- BRAINTRAIN |
- Blog |
- Thinking |
- How to Generate Ideas Faster (and Why the Best Ones Come Late)
Artem Ivanchenko 19.11.2026 1 Comments
You need ten ideas for a weekend promotion and you have two, both of which you've already seen at a competitor's. The usual advice on how to generate ideas faster is to "think outside the box" or wait for inspiration. Neither tells you what to actually do. There are, however, a few very practical things: how to frame the problem, when to switch off your inner critic, how long to keep going after the first slump, and why a walk works better here than coffee.
Why ideas seem to run out after five minutes
Any brainstorm starts out easy. Ideas pour out and you can barely write them down. Then the pace drops, each new thought takes more effort, and you start to feel like the well has gone dry.
Brian Lucas and Loran Nordgren of the Kellogg School of Management call this the creative cliff illusion. In their experiments, people spent a few minutes coming up with ideas and almost always predicted their later ones would be worse. Independent raters saw the opposite: later ideas were more original than early ones. Participants who believed the best ideas come first produced fewer ideas overall, and fewer good ones. The work was published in PNAS in 2020.
What's going on is fairly mundane. Your first ideas sit on the surface. They are things you've already seen, heard or done yourself, and they come easily precisely because there's nothing new in them. Once the obvious runs out, your brain has to start combining things that are far apart, and that's slower. You read the feeling of "this is hard" as "there's nothing left," when it usually means you've finally moved past the predictable stuff.
So when ideas start coming slowly, stay with the problem for another 5 to 10 minutes. That's usually where the thing you sat down for is hiding.
See how quickly you spot hidden connections between concepts: play a few rounds of Odd Word Out. On the harder sets, the feature that links the words is buried deeper, and you have to try several angles.
A quota and a timer instead of inspiration
The fastest way to get lots of ideas looks almost bureaucratic. Set a number and a time limit, say 20 options in 12 minutes. The number should feel slightly uncomfortable. If five come easily, ask yourself for twenty.
A quota does two things. It stops you from quitting at the first slump (that same cliff). And it makes each individual idea cheap, so writing down something silly stops feeling risky. You want the silly ones, because a bad idea often turns into a decent one once you twist it a little.
Practically, you need a sheet of paper, numbers 1 to 20 down the left margin, and a timer. Then put your phone face down. Write short phrases with no explanations and no "but what if." The first five to seven items will be obvious, and that's fine, you need to get them out of your head so they stop looping. Somewhere after number ten it gets interesting. Timer went off and you're on number 14? Give yourself three more minutes.
Honestly, the first few times this feels unpleasant. It seems like you're writing nonsense. Some of it is.
One more condition: nothing else during those 12 minutes. No messages, no "I'll just reply to this one." Every switch resets the chain of associations and sends you back to the obvious. We've written separately about why doing one task at a time pays off more than you'd expect.
How to generate ideas without killing them on the spot
Nearly every creativity technique rests on one rule: quantity first, quality later. It sounds trite, yet most people do the reverse. You come up with an option, immediately think "too expensive," cross it out, and repeat. Each of those checks breaks your rhythm and, worse, trains your brain to offer only safe ideas.
Back in 1987, psychologists Michael Diehl and Wolfgang Stroebe showed that simply expecting to be judged reduces the number of ideas people produce. That held even when people worked alone. Your critic doesn't need to be in the room; the thought that someone will evaluate your list is enough.
So separate the two modes in time. When you're generating, you only write. When you're evaluating, you only choose, and if new ideas pop up, they go on a separate list. A break of at least a few hours between the two helps. With fresh eyes, weak options are easier to spot, and the bold ones look less scary than they did when you wrote them.
Group brainstorming is slower than it looks
Classic brainstorming, with five people in a meeting room taking turns to throw out ideas, was popularized by advertising executive Alex Osborn in the middle of the last century. It has been tested dozens of times since, and the result is consistent. A group produces fewer ideas than the same people would if each worked alone and their lists were combined afterwards. A 1991 meta-analysis by Mullen, Johnson and Salas confirmed this.
Diehl and Stroebe named the main cause production blocking. While a colleague is talking, you wait your turn and hold your thought in your head, and new ones simply don't arrive in the meantime. Some ideas are forgotten before your turn comes. You also unconsciously drift toward what has already been said.
I don't think working on ideas as a team is pointless. Discussion is good for developing options and weeding them out. Generating them, though, works better solo. A format that works: everyone spends 10 minutes writing their own list in silence, the lists are collected, and only then does the conversation start. This is called brainwriting, or the nominal group technique. In a meeting it looks duller than "let's just throw some ideas around," yet it yields more ideas.
Warm up before a session like that: Dobble makes you spot matches between two sets of symbols within seconds and quickly gets your attention into working mode.
Examples at the start narrow your thinking
Everyone tells you to look at what others are doing first, and that advice has a downside. In 1991, researchers David Jansson and Steven Smith gave engineers a design problem and showed some of them an example solution. Those who saw the example were more likely to copy its features, including obviously flawed ones. The effect became known as design fixation, and it has been replicated in many studies since.
Order matters, then. Start with your own list, from your head, no searching. Then look at competitors, Pinterest, your feed, and do a second round. That way other people's solutions become raw material for new combinations instead of a template you can't break away from.
A separate note on your phone during breaks. Scrolling between rounds feeds you the same dose of other people's examples, only random and off topic. There's a separate piece on how your smartphone affects your brain if you want the details.
Walks and breaks, when not thinking helps
In 2014, Marily Oppezzo and Daniel Schwartz at Stanford tested the old habit of thinking on your feet. Participants came up with unusual uses for everyday objects (a classic divergent thinking test), first sitting and then walking. Across the experiments, between 81% and 100% of people gave more creative responses while walking. Walking on a treadmill indoors worked as well as walking outside, and the effect lingered for a while after people sat back down.
There's a detail popular articles usually skip. On problems with a single correct answer, walking didn't help, and walkers even fell slightly behind those who sat. The practical takeaway is simple. Walk when you need to come up with options, and choose between them at your desk.
Incubation is the second useful kind of break. You set the problem aside, do something else, and the solution later seems to arrive on its own. A 2009 meta-analysis by Sio and Ormerod, covering more than a hundred studies, found the effect is real and strongest for tasks that involve generating options. It comes with two conditions, though. You need to work on the problem properly before the break, since longer preparation produced a bigger effect. And the break itself should be light, because demanding mental work during it weakened the effect.
Put simply, "taking a break from the problem" means washing the dishes, walking to the shop or tidying a shelf. Answering client emails doesn't count. Scientists still debate why this works; one explanation is that the brain keeps working on the problem in the background.
Can you train yourself to come up with ideas faster?
No sugar-coating here. There's no direct evidence that any exercises or games make people more creative in general. In research, skills usually transfer only modestly from one type of task to a very different one.
What trains best is generating ideas itself. Try writing a list of 10 ideas a day on any topic: gifts for a friend, names for a cat, twenty uses for an old scarf. The point is to get used to pushing through the obvious zone and not panicking at the slump. Lucas and Nordgren also noticed that people who regularly do creative work are much less prone to the cliff illusion, and their predictions are closer to reality.
Brain training fits in as a warm-up. It loads your attention and working memory, and working memory is where you hold several elements while trying to combine them. Molecular Code or other thinking exercises work well as five minutes before an idea session, though not as a replacement for it.
If you're interested in the long game rather than speed right now, read about developing creative thinking.
What to do with your next problem
- Phrase the problem as one specific question. "How do we bring 30 new customers into the coffee shop this weekend" works better than "come up with a promotion."
- Work alone for 10 to 15 minutes with a quota and a timer, without looking for examples.
- When the ideas dry up, add another 5 minutes.
- Put the problem aside for a few hours and do something simple, ideally on your feet.
- Second round: now look at what others are doing and write down new combinations.
- The next day, separately, pick 2 or 3 options and test them.
For a team, everyone does the first two steps alone and comes to the meeting with a finished list. Half an hour of this usually gets you further than a week of waiting for inspiration.